Cardmatic vs Collectr
Collectr is a strong portfolio tracker for cards and sealed product with native phone apps. Cardmatic is built for collectors who also grade and sell: photo Condition reports, live eBay listing and a desktop workspace.
Collectr details checked October 8, 2026 from its own website and app store listings. Not verified means we could not confirm it from those sources, not that it is missing. Features change, so check their site for the latest.
| Feature | Cardmatic | Collectr |
|---|---|---|
| Scan cards with your phone | YesPhoto and live camera, plus whole binder pages | YesUnlimited scanning on PRO |
| Phone apps | PartlyInstallable web app on iPhone and Android, no app store app | YesiOS and Android |
| Desktop web app | YesFull workspace in the browser | YesWeb app with portfolio and sets |
| Price sources | YesTCGplayer market data and active eBay listings, with source and date shown | YesTCGplayer, eBay and Cardmarket, depending on product |
| Condition or grade estimate from photos | YesPhoto based Condition reports with centering tools, 5 a month free | Not verifiedRaw versus graded prices and population data are shown |
| Create eBay listings | YesLive eBay listing on every plan | Not verifiedShows eBay and TCGplayer listings from other sellers |
| Built in marketplace | NoSell through your own eBay account | PartlyBrowses listings on eBay and TCGplayer |
| CSV import | YesTCGplayer, Collectr, Dragon Shield or a standard CSV | PartlyTCGplayer format, sent to support by email |
| CSV export | PartlySales export on every plan, marketplace CSVs from Pro | YesOn PRO |
| Price | YesFree, then $9.99, $14.99 or $24.99 a month, 20% off yearly | YesFree, PRO $7.99 a month or $59.99 a year |
Cardmatic may suit you if
- You sell on eBay and want to list from the same place you track value.
- You want help deciding whether a card is worth grading.
- You manage a large collection at a desk as well as on your phone.
Collectr may suit you if
- You mainly track value and want a native app store app.
- You track sealed product as much as single cards.
- You want Cardmarket prices alongside US markets.
Switching to Cardmatic
Export your collection from Collectr as a CSV, then use Import CSV on the Cardmatic Upload page. Cardmatic recognises the Collectr format, matches each row to catalog images and prices, and lists any rows it could not match so you can add them by hand.
Try Cardmatic free
Scan a few cards without an account, or create a free account and import your collection.
Sources
- Collectr PRO
- Collectr on the App Store
- Collectr prices and marketplace
- Collectr help: import and export
- Collectr help: prices
Pokémon and other names are trademarks of their owners. Cardmatic is not affiliated with Collectr.